Military Review

The court ordered the concern "Antonov" to pay the Russian Defense Ministry 180 million rubles

36
The Ninth Arbitration Court of Appeal upheld the decision of the lower instance, which, at the request of the Russian Ministry of Defense, collected from the Ukrainian Antonov concern over 180 million rubles. penalty, transfers RIA News information published on the website of the court.



“The Court of Appeal dismissed the concern’s complaint against the decision of the Moscow Arbitration Court, which in November partially granted the claim. Thus, the decision of the court of first instance came into force, ”the material says.

Earlier, the Russian military demanded to recover more than 357 million rubles from the concern. penalties for violation of the latest terms of the development of the aircraft An-70. According to a supplementary agreement to the contract, Antonov was supposed to perform “two phases of work before 25 November 2012, but by September 2016 of the work had not been handed over to the customer, and the delay was 1395 days,” the report said.

In June, the 2014 of the Ministry of Defense of Ukraine notified the Russian side of “the completion of state joint tests of An-70 without the participation of Russian specialists”. The Russian military department, in response, stated that “it considers the tests un-started, and the results obtained by the Ukrainian side, unconfirmed,” follow from the case file.

The arguments of the defendant that the dispute is not within the jurisdiction of the Moscow Arbitration Court was rejected because its competence was “confirmed by an additional agreement to the contract”. Also, the court of first instance did not take into account the arguments of the corporation that “the violation of the deadlines occurred due to the fault of the customer (the Ministry of Defense of the Russian Federation)”.
Photos used:
http://projects.designcodes.ru
36 comments
Ad

Subscribe to our Telegram channel, regularly additional information about the special operation in Ukraine, a large amount of information, videos, something that does not fall on the site: https://t.me/topwar_official

Information
Dear reader, to leave comments on the publication, you must sign in.
  1. cniza
    cniza 31 January 2017 09: 30
    +10
    And it doesn’t matter to them how much and to whom they pay, they still have nothing to pay.
    1. Vend
      Vend 31 January 2017 09: 33
      +5
      Quote: cniza
      And it doesn’t matter to them how much and to whom they pay, they still have nothing to pay.

      How is it nothing? They will pay with land. Sell ​​territory for debts.
      1. bouncyhunter
        bouncyhunter 31 January 2017 09: 41
        +16
        The court ordered the concern "Antonov" to pay the Russian Defense Ministry 180 million rubles

        Well obliged. So, what is next ? Skakuasy on the spindle turned all the courts, obliging them to repay debts.
        1. cniza
          cniza 31 January 2017 09: 53
          +4
          It seems that they are already stuck below the baseboard.
          1. crazyrom
            crazyrom 31 January 2017 23: 38
            0
            They have no money anyway. Let employees pay. Both us and the staff are good.
        2. Lopatov
          Lopatov 31 January 2017 10: 00
          +3
          It is difficult to “turn all the courts on the spindle” when there is property left on the territory of the Russian Federation, and den in Russian banks. facilities.
          1. bouncyhunter
            bouncyhunter 31 January 2017 10: 03
            +10
            So skakuasy do not think beyond one jump.
            1. Lopatov
              Lopatov 31 January 2017 10: 08
              +3
              Judging by the fact that they filed an appeal, they just think the same. There, they do not steer horses, but the Ukrainian oligarchy, which does not want to lose money at all.

              They get very, very big money for the technical support of all Antonov planes in Russia. And for the sake of virtual peramog horses are not going to lose this article of income.
              1. bouncyhunter
                bouncyhunter 31 January 2017 10: 12
                +8
                Yes, they are appealing any claim against them. That's just something I have not heard for a long time that Ukraine, even by a court decision, returned money to someone ...
                1. Lopatov
                  Lopatov 31 January 2017 10: 20
                  +1
                  Where will they go? Technical support of the Russian An-s bypassing Russian banks and not having property and consumables on the territory of Russia is impossible. Refuse- lose a lot of money. So the staff will pay.
                  1. bouncyhunter
                    bouncyhunter 31 January 2017 10: 21
                    +7
                    Well, let's see ... I really hope for your correctness. hi
                  2. kirieeleyson
                    kirieeleyson 31 January 2017 10: 28
                    +2
                    Yes, you are an optimist, there is the 9th appeal going on, already how much they are pulling with this, nothing. They will find the arbitration court by “strong-willed decision,” as they say. I do not believe in the triumph of justice in this matter just because the conjuncturists are mainly here. Assessment of the country's reputation has long been nowhere below, it’s not France with the Mistrals, a round-trip billiard for a week and supposedly “no offense”.
                    1. Lopatov
                      Lopatov 31 January 2017 11: 16
                      0
                      The first appeal. "Ninth Arbitration Court of Appeal" (9th AAC) name of organization
                      1. kirieeleyson
                        kirieeleyson 31 January 2017 11: 24
                        0
                        Yes, I noticed, thanks. hi
        3. 33 Watcher
          33 Watcher 31 January 2017 14: 14
          0
          Quote: bouncyhunter
          The court ordered the concern "Antonov" to pay the Russian Defense Ministry 180 million rubles

          Well obliged. So, what is next ? Skakuasy on the spindle turned all the courts, obliging them to repay debts.

          Well, and the contract, and the additional agreement on it, they still have not terminated. And apparently they do not want to dissolve.
    2. maxim947
      maxim947 31 January 2017 09: 34
      +6
      What kind of sheep are we ?! What are they constantly throwing us at, and we rushing about with our truth ?! They say a national idea is needed, but where to get it if there is no national pride? damn, so much money and time was killed, and, as usual, no one is to blame
    3. uav80
      uav80 31 January 2017 09: 57
      0
      They will not work into slavery for debts yet
      In Russia, they are ready to receive Ukrainian aircraft designers of the Antonov concern and provide them with work
  2. The black
    The black 31 January 2017 09: 32
    +2
    Quote: cniza
    And it doesn’t matter to them how much and to whom they pay, they still have nothing to pay.

    I don’t think that they would have paid even if they had funds. Unfortunately, suing in this situation is a waste of time and money.
  3. Mountain shooter
    Mountain shooter 31 January 2017 09: 34
    +2
    Again Chubaty freebies wanted. Broke off. They won’t return the money, it’s clear to the hedgehogs in the forest.
    Therefore, do not be particularly happy. Yes and no more "Antonov". There is a sign, but no enterprises wassat
  4. weksha50
    weksha50 31 January 2017 09: 35
    +5
    Empty chores ... Nobody will pay anything to anyone ... So, a transfusion from empty to empty ... Empty news ...
  5. Petrol cutter
    Petrol cutter 31 January 2017 09: 36
    +5
    I doubt very much that someone will pay. It’s more like that, for complacency.
  6. The brightest
    The brightest 31 January 2017 09: 59
    +1
    Only collect from whom?
  7. Evil 55
    Evil 55 31 January 2017 10: 01
    +1
    UKRAINE is a mental bankrupt .. hence its problems with its neighbors.
  8. vladimirvn
    vladimirvn 31 January 2017 10: 04
    +1
    “They are smart guys with brains”
    Attorney General Yuri Chaika said he had never helped his sons create a business.
    At the same time, Chaika called the media information about the business of his sons false, for example, about 300 billion rubles of government orders received by his son Igor. “There are no close figures like that, the amount is several times less! - said the Seagull. ... https: //www.znak.com/2017-01-31/genprokuror_yu
    riy_chayka_zayavil_chto_nikogda_ne_pomogla_sozdav
    at_business_svoim_synovyam
    1. _Ugene_
      _Ugene_ 31 January 2017 10: 16
      +2
      And what’s this all about?
      You at least look at the title of the article before writing any nonsense.
    2. Koshak
      Koshak 31 January 2017 11: 42
      +1
      Quote: vladimirvn
      “They are smart guys with brains”
      Attorney General Yuri Chaika said he had never helped his sons create a business ...

      And what, Chaika with his sons has already moved to / from Ukraine and is working in the Antonov concern? What is it from which side to the An-70?
  9. aszzz888
    aszzz888 31 January 2017 10: 10
    +1
    They scared the beggar that they would take away the valuable! There will never be a payment under any circumstances. At least in this case of government.
  10. kirieeleyson
    kirieeleyson 31 January 2017 10: 36
    +3
    It will be difficult to recover money. Here, they argue and it seems like everything is correct, in the legislative framework, with the use of all legal artillery. But how many similar matters do we have, for years, for five years? Thus, it is easier to maintain the process itself, cheaper. Submit the 10th appeal to international courts, then block the president by “strong-willed decision”, start the process again, but with the involvement of a larger amount of information, volume 5 and so on. And there either the sultan will die, or the donkey ..
  11. Charond
    Charond 31 January 2017 11: 03
    +1
    I doubt very much that Bandera Ukraine will comply with the decision of the Russian court.
    1. rotmistr60
      rotmistr60 31 January 2017 11: 35
      +1
      So it will be necessary to send "collectors". They will knock out the deceased.
      1. Charond
        Charond 31 January 2017 14: 15
        0
        Here, instead of collectors, it is necessary to send Iskandirs, right home to Petyun, then maybe he will pay.
  12. Rostislav
    Rostislav 31 January 2017 12: 00
    +1
    There is a court decision, now it remains to come up with a mechanism how to take this money. What they won’t pay is clear to anyone.
    It seems that the only solution is to seek and seize the property of Antonov in Russia.
    Or wait for a change of power. Perhaps not very long.
  13. Const
    Const 31 January 2017 12: 04
    +1
    Quote: bouncyhunter
    gallop.
    This is strong, to the point.
  14. Maz
    Maz 31 January 2017 12: 16
    +2
    And not a word about whose court where it is ... the author seemed to have flown from Mars.
  15. arnulla
    arnulla 1 February 2017 09: 39
    0
    If possible, it is better not to have any business with Ukraine at all.
  16. shura7782
    shura7782 1 February 2017 09: 50
    0
    ......... In June 2014, the Ministry of Defense of Ukraine notified the Russian side "of the completion of state joint tests of the An-70 without the participation of Russian specialists" ......
    Apparently there was still an invitation, but ours decided not to go because of the well-known situation in Ukraine. By and large, there was no need to get involved in this adventure from the very beginning. They themselves are to blame. We can’t see the money.