Military Review

The ECHR replaced the Americans with three thousand dollars to the Americans

37
A message appeared on the website of the European Court of Human Rights (ECHR) stating that the court ruled in favor of 45 American applicants regarding the ban on the adoption of children from Russia by foreign citizens. The American applicants filed lawsuits against Russia, stating that they "had already managed to get acquainted and become attached to Russian orphans, and the Russian authorities suddenly imposed a ban on adoption."


The ECHR replaced the Americans with three thousand dollars to the Americans


The ECHR declared the decision of the Russian authorities "illegal" and "discriminatory". Moreover, the court ruling stated that there was “discrimination based on nationality,” since the ban primarily concerned the adoption of Russian children by American families. The ECtHR obliged Russia to pay a compensation in the amount of 22 thousand dollars to each of 3 American family couples and to cover legal costs in the amount of 600 US dollars.

The only representative of the European Court of Human Rights, who expressed the so-called dissenting opinion, was the Russian judge Dmitry Dedov. According to him, the American reason for complaint is similar to the technical interpretation of the Convention on Human Rights, since the adoption process at the time of the ban was not completed. At the same time, Dmitry Dedov called the amounts of the “issued” fines “more symbolic”. This is a peculiar hint at how mercantile American applicants actually sued Russia, if they are quite happy with the “replacement” of a child with compensation in 3 with more than a thousand dollars ...

By and large, the decision of the ECHR once again gives rise to the topic that Russian laws should have priority on the current situation in the western “elites”, which they are still trying to make Russia dance to the tune.
Photos used:
Expert
37 comments
Ad

Subscribe to our Telegram channel, regularly additional information about the special operation in Ukraine, a large amount of information, videos, something that does not fall on the site: https://t.me/topwar_official

Information
Dear reader, to leave comments on the publication, you must sign in.
  1. 210ox
    210ox 17 January 2017 12: 49
    +8
    To all those who are dissatisfied with giving out dolls ... Let them bring them up.
    1. Zibelew
      Zibelew 17 January 2017 13: 01
      +13
      How many children were taken from Russians in Norway, is the right to family life not infringed on there? But this court does not want to deal with the CIA prisons? It's time to get out of these institutions.
      1. LVMI1980
        LVMI1980 17 January 2017 13: 45
        +5
        Norway is a fascist state.
        at the mention of him, the hands are looking for a machine .....
        so as not to be unfounded
        https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=utVLescQI8s
    2. Evdokim
      Evdokim 17 January 2017 14: 18
      +1
      [quote] [/ quote] Everyone who is unhappy to give out dolls .. Here let them bring up. And Tamagotchi in addition, let them feed according to the schedule. wassat
      1. Zibelew
        Zibelew 17 January 2017 20: 43
        +1
        Homosexuals cannot reproduce there, they decided to come for Russian children. This is human trafficking. And children cannot be goods.
  2. Primipilus
    Primipilus 17 January 2017 12: 53
    +2
    These courts sometimes simply amaze with decisions in their favor.
    1. 210ox
      210ox 17 January 2017 12: 56
      +8
      So in my opinion, our Constitutional Court decided to send these judges to hell
      1. Flinky
        Flinky 17 January 2017 13: 15
        0
        Each promise is strictly individual :)
    2. kuban
      kuban 17 January 2017 14: 17
      +7
      And it cannot be otherwise. We are to blame for everything in advance. They never attracted anyone from the countries of Northern Europe, France, anyone who took their children from their mothers, because they are Russian. We must get out of all these European organizations: courts, PACE. No sense from them.
      1. novel66
        novel66 18 January 2017 07: 44
        +2
        in-vo, it’s time to make all these viable abbreviations illegal on our land. let each other soar the roof
  3. izya top
    izya top 17 January 2017 12: 54
    +3
    The ECHR ordered Russia to pay compensation of $ 22 thousand to each of the 3 American couples and to cover legal costs in the amount of $ 600.
    the cheek will crack
  4. Reserve buildbat
    Reserve buildbat 17 January 2017 12: 55
    +6
    What is the ECHR? Are we obliged to comply with their orders? Maybe Russia will be given to them "by court decision"? Let them sit in their cesspool and not gurgle.
    1. AugustBebel
      AugustBebel 17 January 2017 20: 49
      0
      Of course, international law is more important than national law.
  5. Zaval
    Zaval 17 January 2017 12: 57
    +3
    Execution of this decision, handed down for the sake of "long-suffering Americans", it is not clear why they were trying to adopt Russian children, will be unacceptable stupidity. Russian children should grow up, if not in Russia, then in a mentally related environment.
    1. Homo
      Homo 17 January 2017 13: 58
      0
      Quote: ZAVal
      The execution of this decision, made in favor of the "long-suffering Americans" who, for some unknown reason, were trying to adopt Russian children, would be unacceptable stupidity. Russian children should grow up, if not in Russia, then in a mentally related environment.

      What are you talking about? You have at least read all the letters! In the court decision, not a word about the children, there is only about compensation of $ 3000!
      1. Zaval
        Zaval 17 January 2017 15: 27
        0
        And also about the illegality of the ban on adoption of children from Russia by US citizens. In light of which, compensation for moral damages of 3000 dollars and legal costs arose.
  6. Andrey K
    Andrey K 17 January 2017 12: 58
    +15
    As the saying goes: "Masks have been dropped, gentlemen ..." ...
    The ECHR did not at all notice the reason for pushing the Russian state to limit the adoption of our children by various inadequacies and preoccupied human-like ones. I didn’t notice the murders of our children, our citizens ...
    But he obliged to compensate for the impossibility of bullying our children ...
    Surrealism...
  7. semuil
    semuil 17 January 2017 12: 59
    0
    So have you already prepared the money or not?
  8. Mar.Tirah
    Mar.Tirah 17 January 2017 13: 03
    +3
    It has no legal force for us! And it is not obligatory for execution. There will be a powerful protection of their interests, Russian citizenship, and the guardianship of Russia until adulthood, with constant checks. This is then possible to adopt. In general, it is not patriotic from the Russian state to give your national potential into the wrong hands.
  9. marp
    marp 17 January 2017 13: 07
    +2
    Does the title of the article hurt me alone?
  10. forsait
    forsait 17 January 2017 13: 09
    +4
    We must not forget the main reason for adoption - large tax incentives for amers. They are very profitable, that’s all.
    1. Kenneth
      Kenneth 17 January 2017 13: 18
      0
      It is also very beneficial for us.
  11. Flinky
    Flinky 17 January 2017 13: 13
    +1
    Our COP will simply send the ECHR in writing :)
  12. Mar.Tirah
    Mar.Tirah 17 January 2017 13: 20
    0
    The European Court of Human Rights has ruled on a complaint about a ban on Americans from adopting children from Russia. Instance awarded US citizens € 75 thousand
  13. Awaz
    Awaz 17 January 2017 13: 23
    +3
    surprisingly simple. As far as I know, even after the ban was introduced, Americans adopted children if all the preliminary conditions were met. Therefore, the claims of those who did not pass the procedure or did not pass them and did not meet the requirements are amazing. Well and still, the whole adoption system was corrupt and I would have canceled all adoption acts because of this in place of the Russian authorities. Well and more. It turns out that this Court just supports all sorts of corruption schemes that could not be turned against the Russian Federation, and in general, I don’t think that anyone will implement it. The Russian Federation, as I understand it, does not already consider the decisions of international courts and does not comply if they contradict the constitution. Well, it is clearly seen from the text that this whole court was a fiction and conspiracy. And since the Russian Federation works in this court, it should send all beautifully. Although I do not believe in it. Lawyers there from the Russian Federation shit ... And the full
    1. Burmistr
      Burmistr 17 January 2017 13: 50
      +3
      because it is money, unfortunately, an unsuccessful substitute for honor, conscience, patriotism and human dignity
  14. Stinger
    Stinger 17 January 2017 13: 32
    0
    Give on treshki wooden and send to a known address.
  15. Pirate
    Pirate 17 January 2017 13: 34
    +2
    Is there no one to adopt in the USA?
    But on the other hand, it will be better for a child to grow up in a family than in an orphanage, which at 18 will throw him into adulthood, giving him a room in a communal apartment.
  16. kuban
    kuban 17 January 2017 14: 19
    +5
    Why do we need these useless European organizations: the ECHR, PACE, etc. There is no sense from them, but what do we have, extra money?
  17. Bolo
    Bolo 17 January 2017 14: 47
    +2
    Inexpensive, however, they value a person’s life.
  18. Berkut24
    Berkut24 17 January 2017 15: 27
    +3
    What are American gays and lesbians doing in a European court? The United States is not a member of the ECHR.
  19. Olegmog
    Olegmog 17 January 2017 17: 36
    0
    If they have the opportunity to bring up sick children, let them take it. How inconvenient to talk about it, but these kids will never become a support and support for parents in old age. They will not be left alone at home; they themselves cannot serve themselves. And the state is of no use to these children, and only when one headache grows up.
    1. Kostya Andreev
      Kostya Andreev 18 January 2017 23: 06
      0
      Quote: Olegmog
      but these kids will never become a support and support of parents in old age.

      ask a question, and then write! they very often adopted children and treated them. who will prove to me that this is not so citing the facts of murders, please cite the example of prosperous families.
      I do not support the ECHR and its decision. The ban on the export of children must be sought. not only salvation from sadists by American parents. I think it’s not just that Putin adopted this very unpopular and controversial law! something there was something that did not stop him from the fact that the attitude towards him would not be very.
      I’m embarrassed to ask whether the state is of great benefit to you?
  20. rus-5819
    rus-5819 17 January 2017 18: 48
    0
    "They already managed to get acquainted and become attached to Russian orphans, and the Russian authorities suddenly imposed a ban on adoption."

    Well, move to live in Russia! Many role models: Manson, Seagal ....

    The ECHR ordered Russia to pay compensation of $ 22 thousand to each of the 3 American couples and to cover legal costs in the amount of $ 600.

    Russia has no relations with the EU except "partner"Therefore, the ECHR would be just right to deal with its internal problems and not go into a "foreign monastery" with its own gender charter !!
  21. bogart047
    bogart047 17 January 2017 19: 34
    0
    to give a woman with a poster in the photo a minimum of three children from the orphanage - there will be no time to rally
  22. Gost171
    Gost171 18 January 2017 01: 05
    0
    A big plus for the Russian authorities, children are the future of the country, let these .... learn to make their own. And not only do, but also grow from them full-fledged representatives of the human race.
  23. Vitalson
    Vitalson 18 January 2017 08: 21
    0
    And with what rifle, the ECHR pokes its nose into the internal affairs of our country. This is not potato, but living people. If the authorities have banned adoption, this is an internal matter of the state. And the ECHR does not want to condemn Russia on the water of the drug ban, and then Afghan citizens and the CIA suffer losses in this regard.